IGNOU BSW-041 Solved Question Paper PDF Download

IGNOU BSW-041 Previous Year Solved Question Paper in Hindi

IGNOU BSW-041 Previous Year Solved Question Paper in English

Q1. Explain any two perspectives of tribal studies.

Ans. Two major perspectives that have been influential in shaping the understanding and policies related to tribes in India are as follows: 1. The Isolationist or Colonial Perspective: This perspective was primarily advocated by British administrators and anthropologists. Its core idea was that tribes are ‘primitive’, ‘backward’, and unique cultures that needed to be protected from the corrupting influence of the outside world, especially mainstream Hindu society. A key proponent of this view was Verrier Elwin (in his early phase). He suggested the concept of ‘national parks’ where tribes could live according to their traditional lifestyles without any external interference.

• This perspective viewed tribes as ‘noble savages’ whose culture was to be preserved.
• From an administrative standpoint, it aimed to maintain control over tribal areas while keeping them pacified and isolated.
• Critics argue that this policy denied tribals the benefits of development and progress, effectively turning them into exhibits in an ‘anthropological zoo’.

2. The Assimilationist or Nationalist Perspective:

This perspective is the direct opposite of the isolationist approach. Its foremost proponent was the sociologist

G.S. Ghurye

. He argued that tribes are not separate from Hindu society but are, in fact,

‘backward Hindus’

. He contended that tribal cultures and religions were just localized or incomplete forms of Hinduism, and their natural destiny was to be fully absorbed into the mainstream Hindu fold.

• According to this viewpoint, the solution to tribal problems lies not in their isolation but in their complete merger with the mainstream society.
• This perspective does not value the uniqueness of tribal identities, languages, and cultures, and may view them as an obstacle to national unity.
• As a result of this policy, tribal communities often face the risk of losing their unique cultural identity and control over their land and resources as they get absorbed into the more powerful mainstream economy and culture.

Between these two extreme views, India’s first Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, advocated a middle-path policy of

‘integration’

, which aimed to bring tribes into the mainstream while preserving their cultural identity and dignity.

Q2. Highlight the characteristic features of draft National Tribal Policy.

Ans. The Government of India formulated a draft National Tribal Policy to provide a comprehensive framework for the holistic development and empowerment of tribal communities. Although it is yet to be finalized, its draft contains several significant features that reflect a progressive approach towards tribal rights and development. Its key characteristic features are:

• Rights-based Approach: The policy recognizes tribals not just as ‘beneficiaries’ of welfare schemes but as ‘rights holders’. It emphasizes their constitutional and legal rights.
• Control over Resources (Jal, Jangal, Zameen): The policy acknowledges that tribal life and livelihood are intrinsically linked to water, forest, and land. It emphasizes securing and restoring their traditional rights over these resources through the effective implementation of the Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006 .
• Displacement and Rehabilitation: It stresses minimizing involuntary displacement due to development projects (like dams, mines). Where displacement is unavoidable, the policy provides for fair and timely rehabilitation and resettlement, including ‘land for land’ and a share in the project’s benefits.
• Preservation of Cultural Heritage: The policy gives high priority to the protection and promotion of tribal languages, dialects, traditional knowledge, art, and culture. It also advocates for integrating their culture into the educational curriculum.
• Health and Nutrition: It focuses on providing culturally sensitive and accessible healthcare services to address the high prevalence of malnutrition, anaemia, and other health issues in tribal areas. This includes recognizing traditional healing systems.
• Promoting Self-Governance: It stresses the strengthening of self-governance in tribal areas by empowering Gram Sabhas through the implementation of the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act (PESA), 1996 , in its true spirit.
• Protection from Exploitation: The policy provides for the strict enforcement of existing laws to protect tribals from land alienation, moneylending, and other forms of social and economic exploitation.

In essence, the draft policy aims to promote a model of

integration

rather than isolation or assimilation, one that respects tribal identity and rights while ensuring development.

Q3. Describe the policy of assimilation of tribals in India.

Ans. The policy of assimilation in the context of tribals in India refers to an approach which holds that tribal communities should eventually abandon their distinct cultural, social, and linguistic identities and merge completely into the dominant mainstream society. This perspective tends to view tribal cultures as ‘backward’ or ‘undeveloped’ and believes that their ‘development’ can only occur when they adopt mainstream norms and values. One of the most vocal proponents of this policy was the sociologist G.S. Ghurye . He argued that the tribes of India were essentially “backward Hindus” and had always been a part of Hindu society, albeit on the fringes. According to Ghurye, the solution to their problems lay not in isolation but in their complete integration within the Hindu fold. The process of assimilation operates through various mechanisms:

• Economic Integration: Tribals are encouraged to join the mainstream market economy. This pushes them away from their traditional self-sufficient lifestyles towards wage labour and cash crops, often making them victims of debt and exploitation.
• Educational Policies: The imposition of a uniform national curriculum that often ignores tribal languages, history, and culture alienates the younger generation from their roots and moulds them into the mainstream culture.
• Religious Conversion: Efforts by both Hindu and Christian missionaries have, in many tribal areas, replaced traditional animistic belief systems, leading to profound changes in their social structure and cultural practices.
• Development Projects: The establishment of large-scale dams, mines, and factories in tribal areas has displaced them from their lands and forests, breaking their socio-economic fabric and forcing them to join the mainstream society as labourers.

The policy of assimilation is criticized because it is a form of

ethnocide

, which destroys the unique identities, knowledge systems, and languages of tribal communities. It runs counter to the principle of cultural pluralism promoted by the Indian Constitution, which was better reflected in Jawaharlal Nehru’s policy of ‘integration’, aimed at developing tribes while respecting their culture.

Q4. Discuss the salient features of SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.

Ans. The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 , commonly known as the ‘Atrocities Act’, is a crucial piece of legislation enacted to prevent the commission of offences and atrocities against members of these vulnerable communities. Its objective is not only to punish offenders but also to provide justice, relief, and rehabilitation to the victims. The salient features of this Act are as follows:

1. Comprehensive Definition of ‘Atrocity’: The Act provides a detailed list of specific offences that are considered ‘atrocities’. These are not limited to physical violence but also include acts of social and economic humiliation. For example:
   • Forcing to eat inedible or obnoxious substances.
   • Parading naked or blackening the face.
   • Illegally occupying their land or dispossessing them.
   • Preventing them from using public places or water sources.
   • Imposing a social or economic boycott.
2. Enhanced Punishments: The Act prescribes punishments for offences against SC/ST members that are more stringent than those provided under the Indian Penal Code for similar offences committed by non-SC/ST individuals.
3. Establishment of Special Courts: The Act mandates the establishment of Special Courts to ensure speedy trials and deliver swift justice to the victims. This reduces the delay in litigation.
4. Victim’s Rights and Relief: The Act has provisions for providing immediate relief and rehabilitation to victims and their family members. This includes immediate financial assistance depending on the nature of the crime.
5. Punishment for Neglect of Duty: If a public servant (who is not an SC/ST) wilfully neglects their duties under this Act, there is a provision for their punishment. This makes officials accountable.
6. Bar on Anticipatory Bail: Under Section 18 of the Act, a person accused under this Act cannot be granted anticipatory bail. This is intended to ensure that the accused cannot obstruct the investigation process. (However, this provision has been subject to judicial interpretations).

Thus, this Act is not merely a punitive law but also a corrective and protective measure to ensure that members of the SC and ST communities can live their lives with

dignity, equality, and justice

.

Q5. Explain the diet and nutritional status of the tribals.

Ans. The diet and nutritional status of tribals are deeply linked to their environment, socio-economic conditions, and their interaction with mainstream society. This can be understood in two parts: their traditional diet and their current nutritional status. Traditional Diet: Traditionally, the tribal diet was highly diverse, nutritious, and based on their local ecosystem.

• Dependence on Forest Produce: Their diet was heavily dependent on tubers, roots, fruits, vegetables, leaves, mushrooms, and honey foraged from the forests. These foods were rich in vitamins and minerals.
• Diverse Grains: Instead of rice and wheat, they consumed a variety of millets like ragi, bajra, jowar, and kodo-kutki , which are rich in fibre, protein, and micronutrients.
• Protein Sources: They obtained protein from hunting, fishing, and small animals. Their diet changed with seasonal availability, ensuring a variety of nutrients throughout the year.
• Organic and Natural: This diet was entirely organic, free from pesticides and chemical fertilizers, making it very beneficial for health.

Current Nutritional Status:

Unfortunately, the nutritional status of tribals has seen a drastic decline in recent decades. Today, they are among the most malnourished communities in India.

• Prevalence of Malnutrition: The rates of malnutrition, anaemia, stunting, and wasting among tribal women and children are much higher than the national average.
• Reasons for Decline:
  • Erosion of Access to Forests: Due to deforestation, mining, and restrictive forest laws, they have been deprived of their traditional food sources.
  • Dietary Shift: They have become more dependent on rice and wheat from the Public Distribution System (PDS), which has led to a loss of dietary diversity and reduced consumption of millets.
  • Poverty and Food Insecurity: Due to land alienation and lack of livelihood options, they are unable to purchase nutritious food from the market.
  • Lack of Health Services: Poor access to clean water, sanitation, and health facilities exacerbates the problem of malnutrition.

In summary, tribal communities have moved from a state of dietary self-sufficiency based on a diverse food system to a state of

food insecurity and severe malnutrition

. The solution to their nutritional problems lies not just in providing food, but also in reviving their traditional food systems and restoring their rights over forests and land.

Q6. Describe some of the tribal welfare programmes and development measures in India.

Ans. In line with the provisions of the Constitution, the Government of India has implemented several welfare programmes and development measures for the socio-economic development and protection of tribal communities. These measures aim to bring them at par with the mainstream society while also protecting their distinct identity. Major programmes and measures are as follows: 1. Constitutional Safeguards: The Constitution of India provides special provisions for tribals, such as Article 46 (promotion of educational and economic interests), Article 275 (special grants for tribal welfare), and the Fifth and Sixth Schedules (administration and control of tribal areas). 2. Economic Development Programmes:

• Tribal Sub-Plan (TSP): This is a key strategy under which central and state governments are required to allocate a certain portion of their total budget specifically for tribal development.
• TRIFED (Tribal Co-operative Marketing Development Federation of India): TRIFED works to enhance the income of tribals by ensuring fair prices for their products like handicrafts and forest produce. ‘Tribes India’ outlets are a part of this initiative.
• National Scheduled Tribes Finance and Development Corporation (NSTFDC): This corporation provides loans at concessional rates to tribal entrepreneurs for economic activities.

3. Educational Development Programmes:

• Ashram Schools and Eklavya Model Residential Schools (EMRS): These are residential schools established to provide quality education and lodging facilities to tribal children, so they can complete their studies without hindrance.
• Scholarship Schemes: The government provides various pre-matric and post-matric scholarships to tribal students to encourage them to continue their education.

4. Protection of Rights:

• The Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006: This landmark law recognizes the individual and community forest rights of forest-dwelling tribal communities, thereby securing their livelihoods.
• The PESA Act, 1996: The Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act empowers self-governance in tribal areas by giving the Gram Sabha the authority to make decisions on resources in its territory.

Despite these programmes, challenges like implementation gaps, corruption, lack of awareness, and bureaucratic apathy often prevent the benefits from fully reaching the target population.

Q7. Discuss the problems of tribals in India.

Ans. The tribal communities of India, also known as ‘Adivasis’, form a significant part of the country’s population. Despite their unique cultures and traditions, they face numerous grave problems today that threaten their very existence and identity. These problems can be broadly classified into the following categories: 1. Economic Problems:

• Land Alienation and Displacement: This is the biggest problem faced by tribals. Their lands have been acquired on a massive scale for development projects like dams, mines, and industries, for which they have received inadequate compensation and rehabilitation. Moreover, moneylenders and non-tribals have fraudulently grabbed their lands.
• Denial of Forest Rights: Traditionally, tribal livelihood has depended on ‘Jal, Jangal, Zameen’ (Water, Forest, Land). Due to strict forest laws and deforestation, their access to forests has been restricted, affecting their food security and economic self-sufficiency.
• Poverty and Indebtedness: With the loss of traditional sources of livelihood and a lack of skills for the modern economy, most tribal communities live in extreme poverty. They often take loans from local moneylenders at exorbitant interest rates and get trapped in a vicious cycle of debt.

2. Socio-Cultural Problems:

• Identity Crisis: Contact with mainstream society has endangered their languages, traditions, social institutions, and cultural values. The younger generation is getting alienated from their culture, leading to an identity crisis.
• Health and Malnutrition: Health facilities in tribal areas are almost non-existent. They suffer from high rates of malnutrition, malaria, tuberculosis, and sickle-cell anaemia. Their nutritional status is the worst in the country.
• Problem of Education: Due to poverty, lack of schools, irrelevant curriculum, and language barriers, the dropout rate among tribal children is very high.

3. Political and Administrative Problems:

• Exploitation and Atrocities: Tribal people are often victims of various forms of exploitation, violence, and atrocities by non-tribals and government officials. Despite the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act , the situation remains alarming.
• Weak Implementation of Laws: Progressive laws like PESA and the Forest Rights Act (FRA) have not been implemented in their true spirit, denying tribals the right to self-governance and control over their resources.

In short, tribal communities today are facing a double-edged sword of development – on one hand, they are deprived of development, and on the other, they are being displaced and exploited in the name of development.

Q8. What do you understand by empowerment of women? Discuss.

Ans. Women’s empowerment is a multi-dimensional and dynamic process that aims to provide women with the power, agency, and authority to make their own life choices and control their own destinies. It is not just about benefiting women; it is a process through which they challenge the existing power structures in society and achieve gender equality. Empowerment is not power ‘given’ by someone, but rather the ability ‘gained’ by oneself. The key dimensions of women’s empowerment are as follows:

• Social Empowerment: This means ensuring women a dignified place in society and freeing them from patriarchal norms and social evils like child marriage, dowry, and domestic violence. Equal access to education and health is the foundation of social empowerment. An educated and healthy woman is more aware of her rights.
• Economic Empowerment: This focuses on making women financially independent and self-reliant. It includes the right to own property, equal opportunities in employment, equal pay for equal work, and control over their own income. When women are economically empowered, their decision-making power in the family and society increases.
• Political Empowerment: This implies ensuring women’s active participation in political processes and institutions. It is not limited to just casting a vote, but includes their presence and voice in policy-making and governance at all levels – from the Gram Panchayat to the Parliament. The reservation for women in local bodies through the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments in India was a significant step towards political empowerment.
• Psychological Empowerment: This is an internal aspect of empowerment. It means the development of self-confidence, self-esteem, and a sense of ‘I can’ in women. It gives them the courage to believe in their abilities and break the socio-cultural barriers that hold them back.

In conclusion, women’s empowerment is a holistic concept. It cannot be achieved through a single scheme or law. It requires legal reforms, educational opportunities, economic freedom, and, most importantly, a profound change in the social mindset. When women are empowered, it is not only they who benefit, but the entire family, society, and nation that progresses.