IGNOU BHIC-131 Solved Question Paper PDF Download

IGNOU BHIC-131 Previous Year Solved Question Paper in Hindi

IGNOU BHIC-131 Previous Year Solved Question Paper in English

Q1. Critically examine various methods used to analyse archaeological data.

Ans. Archaeological data is crucial for archaeologists to reconstruct the past. Several scientific methods are employed to analyze this data to extract maximum and accurate information. A critical examination of these methods is as follows: 1. Stratigraphy: This is a fundamental method in archaeology, involving the study of layers (strata) during the excavation of a site. The basic principle is that the lowest layer is the oldest and the uppermost layer is the most recent. This helps in establishing a relative chronology of different cultures. Critique: This method is reliable only when the strata are undisturbed. Later activities, such as the digging of pits, animal burrows, or construction work, can disturb the stratigraphy, leading to incorrect conclusions. 2. Typology: In this method, artifacts (like pottery, tools) are classified based on their style, shape, and manufacturing technique. It is assumed that the style of an object evolves gradually over time. This helps in establishing relationships between artifacts found at different sites and creating a relative timeline. Critique: Changes in style are not always linear or uniform. Different styles may coexist at the same time in different regions, and sometimes older styles may come back into vogue. 3. Radiocarbon Dating (C-14): This is an absolute dating method. It measures the decay of the Carbon-14 isotope present in organic materials (like wood, bone, charcoal). All living organisms absorb C-14, and after death, it decays at a known rate. It is very useful for determining the age of objects up to 50,000 years old. Critique: This method has a margin of error (± a few years). Contamination of the sample can affect the results. Furthermore, results need to be calibrated due to variations in the amount of C-14 in the atmosphere over time. 4. Thermoluminescence (TL) Dating: This method is used to determine the age of objects made from fired clay, such as pottery and bricks. It measures the time since the object was last heated. Critique: It is less precise than C-14 dating and has a larger margin of error. 5. Palaeobotany and Palaeozoology: These methods involve the study of ancient plant remains (pollen, seeds) and animal bones. This provides valuable information about the environment, climate, diet, and agricultural practices of the period. In conclusion, no single method is perfect on its own. Archaeologists use these different methods in conjunction to arrive at reliable conclusions. Only by cross-verifying the results of one method with another does a more accurate and comprehensive picture of the past emerge.

Q2. Discuss various theories of the decline of the Harappan civilization.

Ans. The Harappan civilization, the first urban civilization of the Indian subcontinent, began to decline around 1900 BCE. No single cause can be held responsible for its decline; rather, it was the result of a complex process involving multiple factors. Various scholars have proposed the following theories for its decline: 1. The Theory of Foreign Invasion: Initially, scholars like Sir Mortimer Wheeler proposed that an Aryan invasion destroyed the Harappan civilization. He cited the skeletons found at Mohenjo-daro and the mention of ‘pur’ (forts) and Indra as ‘Purandara’ (destroyer of forts) in the Rigveda. Critique: This theory is now rejected by most scholars because:

• There is no concrete archaeological evidence of an invasion. The skeletons do not belong to the same time and place.
• There is a significant chronological gap between the decline of Harappa and the arrival of the Aryans.
• Elements of continuity are visible in post-Harappan cultures, suggesting a gradual transition rather than an abrupt destruction.

2. Climate and Environmental Change:

This theory is the most widely accepted today. It includes several sub-theories:

• Drying or Shifting of Rivers: Many scholars believe that the drying up of the Ghaggar-Hakra river (often identified with the ancient Saraswati) or the shifting of the courses of the Yamuna and Sutlej was a major cause of decline. This severely affected agricultural production and led to the abandonment of many settlements.
• Floods and Tectonic Disturbances: Geologists like M.R. Sahni and Robert Raikes have presented evidence of repeated devastating floods at sites like Mohenjo-daro, possibly caused by tectonic uplift.
• Over-exploitation of Resources: Large-scale deforestation for baking bricks and for construction disrupted the ecological balance, leading to a decrease in soil fertility and a drier climate.

3. Economic Decline:

Some scholars argue that the decline in Harappan trade with Mesopotamia weakened the urban economy. A decline in craft production and the lack of maintenance of urban centers are considered evidence of this.

4. Socio-political Disintegration:

It is also possible that the unified political structure of the Harappan civilization weakened. The collapse of central authority led to a failure in maintaining civic amenities (like drainage) and resulted in overcrowding and disorder in the cities.

In conclusion, the “decline” of the Harappan civilization was not a sudden end but a gradual process of “de-urbanization”. After the collapse of urban centers, the population shifted to rural settlements, and Harappan traditions survived in a transformed form in later rural cultures (like the Jhukar and Jhangar cultures). The decline was likely the result of a combination of environmental changes and internal weaknesses.

Q3. Discuss briefly the early iron age culture of South India.

Ans. The Early Iron Age in South India (circa 1000 BCE to 300 BCE) is primarily identified with the Megalithic Culture . This culture is named after the monuments built with large stones (megaliths) to bury the dead. This culture was widespread south of the Vindhyas, especially in the regions of Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka, and Andhra Pradesh. Megalithic Burials: The main purpose of these monuments was to house the remains of the deceased. They were of several types:

• Cairn circles: A circle of stones with a burial in the center.
• Dolmen: A chamber made by placing a large stone slab on large stone pillars.
• Cist: An underground rectangular box made of stone slabs.
• Menhir: A huge stone pillar erected as a memorial.

The construction of these burials required social labor and organization, indicating an organized society.

Economy and Technology:

The most significant feature of the Megalithic culture was the

widespread use of iron

. A large number of iron tools and weapons have been found in the burials, such as:

• Agricultural tools: Hoes, sickles, and spades, which indicate the expansion and intensification of agriculture. This made surplus production possible.
• Weapons: Swords, daggers, spears, and arrows, which indicate the importance of warfare and hunting.

Iron technology made it possible to clear dense forests and cultivate hard soil, leading to the expansion of settlements.

Society and Culture:

Artifacts from the burials provide information about the society:

• Pottery: The characteristic pottery of this period is the Black and Red Ware , often used as burial urns.
• Crafts: Besides blacksmiths, there were bead makers and goldsmiths, as evidenced by gold jewelry and beads of precious stones found in graves.
• Social Stratification: The difference in the size of the burials and the quantity of goods placed in them points to a stratified society, where some chiefs or elites had a higher status than others.

Although these people were not familiar with writing, this culture laid the foundation for the later Sangam Age, which gives a glimpse of the chiefs and tribal societies described in Sangam literature. Thus, the Megalithic Iron Age in South India laid the groundwork for the process of state formation.

Q4. Write short notes on any two of the following in about 200 words each : (a) Vedic Literature (b) Formation of regions in early India (c) Early farmers of the Nile Valley and West Asia (d) NBPW Culture

Ans. (a) Vedic Literature Vedic literature is the oldest literary source of ancient India, composed between approximately 1500 BCE and 600 BCE. It throws light on the religious, social, and political life of the Aryans. It is divided into two main parts: Shruti (that which is heard, i.e., divine knowledge) and Smriti (that which is remembered). The Shruti literature includes the four Vedas:

• Rigveda: It is the oldest Veda, containing 1028 hymns in praise of the gods. It is the main source of information for the society and religion of the Early Vedic period (1500-1000 BCE).
• Samaveda: It contains chants to be sung during sacrifices. It is considered the origin of Indian music.
• Yajurveda: It describes the ritual rules and procedures for sacrifices.
• Atharvaveda: It contains spells and charms related to magic, healing of diseases, and popular beliefs.

Attached to each Veda are the Brahmanas (commentaries on sacrifices), Aranyakas (philosophical texts written in the forest), and Upanishads (profound reflections on the soul, Brahman, and the mysteries of creation). The Upanishads are also called ‘Vedanta’. This vast body of literature is not only a religious text but also an invaluable source for reconstructing early Indian history.

(d) NBPW Culture

Northern Black Polished Ware (NBPW) is a distinctive type of pottery that was prevalent in ancient India between approximately 700 BCE and 200 BCE. It is a key archaeological indicator of the

Second Urbanization

in the Indian subcontinent.

Its main features are:

• Appearance: It is a very fine, thin-textured ware with a glossy, coal-black polish on its surface. It was fired at a very high temperature, giving it a metallic sheen and sound.
• Luxury item: Due to its high quality and limited availability, it is considered a luxury item, likely used by the wealthy class.
• Cultural association: The NBPW culture is associated with the rise of the Mahajanapadas, the increasing use of iron, the circulation of punch-marked coins, and the development of new religious movements like Buddhism and Jainism.
• Geographical spread: Although its heartland was the middle Ganga valley, it has been found throughout the subcontinent, from Taxila to South India and Bengal, through trade, indicating the extensive trade networks of the period.

In short, NBPW is not just a type of pottery but a symbol of a crucial period that laid the foundation for urban life and state-level societies in India.

Q5. Examine the image of cities as reflected in literature and archaeology.

Ans. Literature and archaeology are the two primary sources for studying the rise of cities in ancient India, especially during the Second Urbanization of the 6th century BCE. Both sources present a vivid picture of cities, but they differ in their perspectives and the information they provide. The Image of Cities in Archaeology: Archaeology provides us with concrete evidence about the physical form and structure of cities. Archaeological excavations reveal the following:

• Fortifications: Most major cities like Kaushambi, Rajgir, and Ujjain were surrounded by massive mud or brick walls, symbolizing security and power.
• Buildings and Structures: The extensive use of baked bricks, planned streets (though often irregular), advanced drainage systems (like soakage pits and drains), and public buildings (such as pillared halls, granaries) are evidence of an organized civic life.
• Economic Activities: Remains of various craft centers, such as bead-making and metalworking workshops, have been found. The presence of punch-marked coins and high-quality pottery like NBPW indicates a prosperous commercial economy and long-distance trade.
• Religious Structures: Early forms of stupas, monasteries, and temples were also part of the urban landscape.

Archaeology gives us an objective picture of the size, density, and economic base of cities.

The Image of Cities in Literature:

Literary sources, especially Buddhist and Jaina texts, provide insights into the social and cultural life of cities.

• Buddhist Texts: The Pali Tripitaka mentions six great cities (mahanagaras): Champa, Rajagriha, Shravasti, Saketa, Kaushambi, and Varanasi. In these texts, cities are depicted as bustling centers inhabited by kings, ministers, wealthy merchants ( setthis ), artisans, and monks. Cities were centers of trade, politics, and intellectual debate. The Buddha delivered most of his sermons in these cities. However, the literature also mentions the negative aspects of cities, such as noise, crowds, and moral decay.
• Arthashastra: Kautilya’s Arthashastra provides a detailed plan for an ideal capital city ( durga ), with a grid of streets, separate residential areas for different varnas, and designated locations for administrative buildings. This is a prescriptive text that reflects the state’s perspective.
• Sangam Literature: It describes South Indian port cities like Puhar and Madurai, with their busy markets, tall buildings, and foreign traders (Yavanas).

Conclusion:

Archaeology and literature are complementary. Archaeology confirms the physical structures described in literature, such as fortifications and markets. It provides tangible proof of the economic foundation of cities. On the other hand, literature breathes life into these physical structures, telling us about the inhabitants of the cities, their social relations, their aspirations, and their worldview. Archaeology answers ‘what’ and ‘how’, while literature often sheds light on ‘who’ and ‘why’. Only by studying both together does a holistic and nuanced image of ancient Indian cities emerge.

Q6. Write a note on Alexander’s invasion and its impact.

Ans. The invasion of India by Alexander the Great of Macedonia (327-325 BCE) is a significant event in ancient Indian history. Although this invasion was short-lived, it had far-reaching political, economic, and cultural impacts. The Invasion: After conquering the Persian Empire, Alexander turned towards India as part of his ambition for world conquest. He entered the Indian subcontinent through the Khyber Pass. At that time, North-West India was divided into many small kingdoms and republics, which were in conflict with each other. Alexander easily subdued some local rulers like Ambhi, the king of Taxila. His most famous battle was against King Porus (Puru) on the banks of the river Jhelum (Hydaspes). Although Porus fought valiantly, he was defeated by Alexander’s superior strategy. Impressed by Porus’s bravery, Alexander returned his kingdom and made him an ally. Alexander’s army reached the Beas (Hyphasis) river, but his tired and homesick soldiers refused to advance further. This mutiny forced Alexander to turn back. He divided his army into two parts—one by sea and the other by land—and departed from India in 325 BCE. The Impact: The effects of Alexander’s invasion can be understood under the following headings:

• Political Impact: Alexander’s direct political control was very short-lived. Soon after his death, the satraps (governors) appointed by him were either killed or fled from India. However, it had a significant indirect effect. Alexander’s invasion weakened the small states of North-West India, making it easier for Chandragupta Maurya to conquer this region and establish the Mauryan Empire. For the first time, it inspired the idea of creating a unified political entity in India.
• Economic Impact: The invasion opened up new land and sea routes for direct contact between India and the West. It boosted trade and commerce, which flourished in the subsequent centuries. Alexander also founded several new cities in his empire, which became centers of trade.
• Cultural Impact: This was the most lasting impact of the invasion.
  • Historiography: The Greek historians who accompanied Alexander wrote detailed, dated accounts of India. This provided a definite chronological framework for events in Indian history, which was absent in earlier Indian sources.
  • Art and Architecture: The fusion of Indian and Greek (Hellenistic) art gave birth to the Gandhara school of art . In this style, statues of the Buddha and Bodhisattvas were made with realistic physical anatomy and drapery, similar to Greek gods.
  • Numismatics: Later Indo-Greek rulers introduced artistic and realistic portrait coins, which profoundly influenced the Indian tradition of coinage.

In conclusion, although Alexander’s invasion was incomplete as a military success, it placed India on the world stage and laid the foundation for cultural and economic exchanges that influenced both civilizations for centuries.

Q7. Critically analyse the early state formation in the early Tamilaham region.

Ans. The process of state formation in early Tamilaham, also known as the Sangam Age (c. 300 BCE – 300 CE), was different from that in the Gangetic plains of North India. A critical analysis requires us to consider both Sangam literature and archaeological evidence. Elements of a State: Sangam literature, especially the ‘Puram’ poems, tells us about three major dynasties – the Cheras, Cholas, and Pandyas , known as the ‘Muvendar’ (the three crowned kings). Besides them, there were many minor chieftains ( Velirs ). These polities possessed some elements of a state:

• King and Capital: The Muvendar had hereditary kings, royal emblems (like the bow of the Cheras, the tiger of the Cholas, and the fish of the Pandyas), and fortified capitals (e.g., Madurai, Puhar, Vanji).
• Revenue: They collected regular taxes ( kadamai ) and tribute ( irai ). Tolls were also collected on trade routes and at ports.
• War and Army: Warfare was central to the polity. Kings maintained their armies and frequently raided each other’s territories for plunder. The redistribution of war booty among chieftains and poets was the basis of the king’s power.
• Justice and Assembly: The king was the supreme judge and had his court ( avai ), where he sat with his advisors.

Critical Analysis and Limitations:

Despite the above elements, the polity of Tamilaham cannot be described as a full-fledged, bureaucratic state like the Mauryan Empire. It had several limitations:

• Fluid Territories: The king’s control was not over a fixed, clearly defined territory but depended on his personal influence and military power. Territories constantly expanded and contracted due to wars.
• Undeveloped Bureaucracy: There was a lack of an elaborate, hierarchical bureaucracy like that of the Mauryas. Administration was largely based on kinship and personal relationships.
• Revenue System: Revenue was mainly based on plunder and tribute, not on a systematic taxation system based on agricultural surplus. It has also been described as a ‘predatory polity’.
• Social Structure: Society was based on clan and kinship groups ( kuti ) rather than the varna system.

Conclusion:

Therefore, the polity of early Tamilaham can be best understood as a transitional stage between a ‘chiefdom’ and an ‘early state’. It was a ‘segmentary state’, where the king’s power was strongest at the center and diminished towards the periphery, where local chieftains were more autonomous. It was not a fully formed state, but the process of state formation was clearly underway, driven by the expansion of agriculture, the growth of trade, and constant warfare.

Q8. Write short notes on any two of the following in about 200 words each : (a) Janapada (b) The Ajivikas (c) The Shungas and the Kharavelas (d) Roman coins

Ans. (a) Janapada The word ‘Janapada’ literally means ‘the foothold of a tribe’ ( jana = tribe/people, pada = foot). It refers to the territory where a ‘jana’ or tribe began to settle down. This concept became important in the Later Vedic period (c. 1000-600 BCE), when the semi-nomadic Aryan tribes of the Early Vedic period settled permanently in the Ganga-Yamuna doab and adopted an agriculture-based lifestyle. The emergence of Janapadas was a crucial stage in the process of state formation. The king’s authority now extended over a specific territory, not just the tribe. The king’s power increased, which was demonstrated through massive sacrifices like the Ashvamedha and Rajasuya. Famous Janapadas like Kuru, Panchala, Kashi, and Kosala emerged during this period. Many of these Janapadas later evolved and transformed into the Mahajanapadas (great janapadas) by the 6th century BCE, which were the first major states in early Indian history. Thus, the Janapada represented the transition from a tribal society to a territorial state. (b) The Ajivikas The Ajivika sect was a major atheistic (Shramana) school of thought that emerged alongside Buddhism and Jainism in the 6th century BCE. Its founder was Makkhali Gosala , a contemporary of Mahavira and the Buddha. The central philosophy of the Ajivikas was the doctrine of ‘Niyati’ (fate or destiny). They believed that everything in the universe is pre-determined and cannot be changed by human actions or efforts. According to them, every soul must pass through a fixed cycle of births to attain salvation, and no penance or good deeds can hasten or slow it down. Due to this fatalism, they often faced criticism in Buddhist and Jaina texts. Ajivika monks followed rigorous austerities and were often naked. The sect received patronage from the Mauryan emperor Bindusara, and Ashoka also donated the Barabar caves to the Ajivikas. However, in the subsequent centuries, it could not compete with Buddhism and Jainism and gradually became extinct.